Author ORCID Identifier

Crystal L. Hoyt: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9108-3910

Abstract

People who are motivated to challenge the gender hierarchy may evaluate leaders in ways that match those beliefs. Across two studies (N = 915), we examined whether gender system‐challenging beliefs predicted biased evaluations by manipulating CEO gender as well as leadership style (Study 1) and personal values expressed about gender equality (Study 2). In Study 1, participants evaluated a female or male CEO who displayed either a competent or dominant leadership style. Participants higher in system‐challenging beliefs evaluated the male leader less favorably, whereas those lower in these beliefs showed no
bias. This pattern did not depend on leadership style. In Study 2, participants evaluated a female or male CEO who either publicly supported or challenged the existing gender hierarchy. Participants higher in system‐challenging beliefs evaluated male leaders and leaders who supported the hierarchy less favorably than female leaders and those who challenged it, whereas those lower in these beliefs did not distinguish between them. Comparisons with a control condition suggested that this pattern reflected the devaluation of leaders who defended the hierarchy rather than the elevation of those who challenged it. Together,
these findings show that system‐challenging beliefs shape evaluations of incumbent leaders based on both their gender and their stance toward the gender status quo.

Document Type

Article

Publication Date

11-17-2026

Publisher Statement

© 2026 The Author(s). Journal of Applied Social Psychologypublished by Wiley Periodicals LLC.

Share

COinS