Rethinking Music Copyright Infringement In The Digital World: Proposing a Streamlined Test After the Demise of the Inverse Ratio Rule

Authors

Christina R. Dimeo, University of Richmond School of Law

Abstract

This Comment will discuss the devastating blow to musicians inflicted by the Blurred Lines verdict’s embrace of the inverse ratio rule. Then, I will examine the Stairway to Heaven decision, in which the Ninth Circuit sharply changed course and decided to abrogate the inverse ratio rule. This welcome policy change nevertheless leaves questions as to how the Ninth Circuit will balance considerations of access with substantial similarity as it assesses copying in future cases. More importantly, the explosion of access in the digital world has fatally weakened—across all circuits—the role of access within the infringement test. In that light, I will conclude with a modified standard by which music copyright infringement cases should be judged.

Recommended Citation

Christina R. Dimeo, Rethinking Music Copyright Infringement In The Digital World: Proposing a Streamlined Test After the Demise of the Inverse Ratio Rule, 55 U. Rich. L. Rev. 1077 (2021).
Available at: https://scholarship.richmond.edu/lawreview/vol55/iss3/9